Birmingham, UK: “A million people with a speech impediment”

February 5, 2010

A million people live there and it’s the second-largest city in Great Britain. I lived there briefly in 2000-2001 for an ill-advised tilt at graduate school at the University of Birmingham. The poor city: it’s mostly reviled by the British and ignored by the rest of the world.

Birmingham natives have one of the most easily-recognizable regional accents of the entire English collection. And it has about as much cachet as New Jersey. The “Brummie” accent (Brummie is a general epithet for all things Birmingham-ish because, see, you can’t really make an adjective out of Birmingham easily) is distinctive and quite often ridiculed. People from Southern England especially dislike the sound of it, leading a guy in a video called “Birmingham: Reputation vs. Reality” to claim that the city consists of “a million people with a speech impediment.” How tolerant.

I think Brummie accents are kind of endearing. Hallmarks of it (at least to my rather un-nuanced ear) include a lot of “ai” sounds and a tendency to rise in tone such that the speaker often sounds like he or she is asking a lot of questions mid-sentence. Finding solid examples of it online is hard because the vast majority of accent-related videos on YouTube are people imitating accents. The most classic expression of it I ever heard was when I was walking, glumly, one night in the mid-winter along the canal near the university and a grizzly middle-aged man walked past and said, out of nowhere, “Cheer up, love.” Yes, they say “love” quite nicely. It is, as a young woman says in the video, like “Brummies sing at people.”

Here’s part one of the Reputation vs. Reality series. I find it fascinating, but then again, I lived in Birmingham. Interesting coverage of accents starts a couple of minutes in.

While we’re on the subject of accents, this video of a woman imitating 21 accents is fairly eerie and nifty. She doesn’t quite nail all of them 100% but it’s pretty impressive:

One Comment

  1. Todd says:

    I can’t hear it. They were interviewing people from Birmingham, but even those people had to exaggerate to show what they thought a Brummie accent was like. At best, I can distinguish between broad regions/countries (e.g. Scotland, Ireland). City-level accents evade me. But then, I haven’t spent much time listening to people from the U.K. except for our trip to Scotland.

    As for the “21 Accents” lady, that was eerie, though some her Sydney, Australian, and Texan accents were the worst for me. And what’s the difference between a “Seattle” accent and a “California” one? I didn’t really hear it. It was interesting to discover what her real accent is (could you guess?).

Related Posts

Scipio the Computer has deemed that these might be similar in content!
Wonderful games with Caslon