Well-Written Stuff I Don't Agree With

May 22, 2008

I stumbled upon a long thread tonight in the LibraryThing discussion forums. It’s a topic in the “Political Conservatives” group. It kind of blew my mind–and not in the way you might think.

The posts there are considerate, informed, well-executed and, in several cases, remarkably well-written. Perhaps it’s because it’s thread on a site about books. But the authors, in almost all cases, are not flinging buzzwords and insults. They’re slinging thoughts. I may not agree with the politics (nor the logic), but a) I appreciate the tone and care of the arguments; and b) I’m willing to entertain and evaluate the ideas therein because of this tone and care–I’m not just thrown into a state of frustration and reaction. It’s refreshing.

That’s all. See what you think. Maybe my impression is whacko.

Disclaimer: Some of the posts in the thread are slightly inflammatory. I’m just saying most are not.

Related Posts

Scipio the Computer has deemed that these might be similar in content!
Wonderful games with Caslon